Christian and Missionary Alliance Breaks Tradition Allowing Women to be Ordained as Pastors

Female Pastor
Pixabay/ Andrys Stienstra

The Christian and Missionary Alliance (CMA) has historically decided to ordain women as pastors, marking a significant departure from its tradition. The decision comes after four years of extensive official discussions and debates within the organization.

Ordination of Women

Christianity Today reported that CMA, which consists of approximately 2,000 churches in the United States, saw over 60 percent of its delegates approve the changes at the Alliance's general council held in Spokane, Washington, last week. The CMA aims to rectify this disparity and provide equal opportunities for all aspiring pastors. By recognizing the calling and qualifications of women to serve as pastors, the denomination takes a significant step toward inclusivity and gender equality, as reported. While endorsing the modifications, John Stumbo, the Alliance's president, emphasized acknowledging diverse interpretations of New Testament passages concerning church leadership. Stumbo stated that while the denomination required unity, it did not demand uniformity. As a result, churches that embrace the ordination of women and those that hold a different stance can still collaborate effectively in spreading the gospel. 

However, Christian Headlines reported that critics of their viewpoint voiced apprehensions about the potential consequences of ordaining women into leadership positions, cautioning against what they perceived as a "liberal slide." Paul Taylor, the esteemed pastor of Discovery Alliance Church in Missoula, Montana, articulated their stance with conviction. He emphasized the significance of upholding the roles of men within the body of Christ and the authority bestowed upon shepherds by God through His Word. According to Taylor, adopting such changes would jeopardize sacred roles and potentially lead to the withdrawal of God's blessings.

Also Read: Saddleback Church Expelled by Southern Baptist Convention Over Women Pastors Debate

Pope Francis on Ordaining Women

According to the Catholic News Agency, Pope Francis clarified that women cannot be ordained as priests within the Catholic Church. As mentioned, he emphasized the crucial role that women play in the life of the Church, shedding light on the need for further development of theology centered on the "Marian principle." Addressing the question of women's ordination, Pope Francis expressed his unwavering stance, stating, "And why can a woman not enter ordained ministry? It is because the Petrine principle has no place for that." According to the Holy Father, the Petrine principle represents the ministry aspect of the Church, and he referred to it as the "ministerial dimension" associated with ordained service. Additionally, the pope also pointed out the need for further theological exploration of the Marian principle. He acknowledged that a comprehensive theology embracing the role of women as exemplified by the spousal and feminine nature of the Church is yet to be fully developed. 

Furthermore, Pope Francis's remarks reaffirm the Catholic Church's position on women's ordination while emphasizing the vital role of women within the Church community. His call for further theological exploration of the Marian principle signals an intention to develop a more comprehensive understanding of women's place in the Church. As the Catholic Church continues to navigate discussions surrounding gender roles and inclusivity, Pope Francis' comments provide insight into his perspective, highlighting the importance of the Petrine and Marian principles in shaping the Church's identity.

Related Article: Southern Baptist Convention Cut Ties with Saddleback Church Over Decision of Ordaining Three Women Pastors